№ 009217 NOVEMBER 2026DEATHLONGWOOD HOUSE, SAINT HELENA
The Death of Napoleon
The Doctor Who Wouldn't Sign Napoleon's Autopsy
Unsolved since 1821On May 6, 1821, Napoleon's physician cut open the body and found advanced stomach cancer. The British doctors in the room signed a report contradicting him on almost everything else. Arsenic had been in his hair for years. No one has ever agreed on why, or how much it mattered.
What We Know
Francesco Antommarchi was thirty years old, Corsican, and by his own era's standards not a particularly seasoned physician, when British soldiers at Longwood House sent for him on the afternoon of May 6, 1821. He had spent nearly twenty months as Napoleon Bonaparte's personal doctor on Saint Helena, the remote South Atlantic island where the British held their prisoner after Waterloo, watching his patient's stomach pain worsen into vomiting, then fever, then the black, coffee-ground vomit that preceded his death the day before. Now it was Antommarchi's job to open the body and say why.
He worked in a room crowded with witnesses: seven British medical officers, sent to observe an autopsy on the man their government had exiled. On the stomach, everyone agreed. It was a mass of cancerous disease covering nearly the whole gastric wall, with a perforated ulcer near the outlet large enough to admit a finger, the organ filled with dark fluid from internal bleeding. On the lungs and liver, the room split in two. Antommarchi's own notes describe tuberculosis in the lungs and a liver swollen with chronic hepatitis. The British doctors' official report, principally written by Dr. Thomas Shortt, called the lungs "quite sound" and the liver ordinary size. Antommarchi refused to sign it.
That refusal is easy to lose in the larger story, but it's the whole problem in miniature: two physicians, over the same open body, on the same afternoon, couldn't agree on what they were looking at. Layered on top of it was something neither man could test for. Decades later, chemists analyzing preserved locks of Napoleon's hair would find arsenic at roughly ten times a modern reference level, not only in hair cut near his death, but in a sample dated to 1805, sixteen years before Saint Helena existed as a possibility for anyone.
That's what's established. The rest — why the question has held out this long, the four theories still standing, and the ballot where you pick one — takes about four more minutes.
Read the rest →